I keep seeing profiles outside of my search filters

The way our app works is that it will show you users based on your current GPS location. That being said, you may be seeing users from a different state that is currently in your city, for example, on business or vacation.

 

We also have a First Class membership that allows users to search in specific locations from where they are currently, which can explain seeing users from different cities.

 

This feature is specifically called Passport and if you would like, can update your account to First Class by going to Settings--> Upgrade to First Class.